Securing Our Future: Making Climate Finance Work for Agricultural Soil
Nov 11, 2024, Global
Executive Summary
Note: The usage of the term “Regenerative Agroecology” in this brief refers to regenerative agriculture, agroecology, and any sustainable soil management system that increases organic matter and life in agricultural soils, and that also encompasses the principles of Conservation Agriculture as defined by FAO and GSP, namely: no tillage, permanent soil cover, integrating plant and animal litter into soil, and crop diversification. A sustainable soil management system includes the 4 principles of supporting services, provisioning services, regulating services, and cultural services. The effects of such a system include healthy living soils, plant and animal health, human health, improved farmer livelihoods, biodiversity and ecosystem restoration, sustainable economies and food systems.
Healthy soil is crucial for climate resilience, food security and economic growth. However, soil degradation threatens agroecosystem benefits, with 40% of global land already degraded and 90% of Earth's topsoil at risk by 2050.
Agricultural soil can play a significant role in our efforts to adapt to and mitigate the impact of climate change. If regenerative agroecological practices are adopted across the globe, a staggering 27% of the carbon sequestration needed to keep global temperatures below a 2∘C rise beyond pre-industrial levels could be realized. However, financial incentives are critical for farmers to transition away from agricultural methods that are harmful to soil health, which have become conventional and resulted in significant greenhouse gas emissions.
For 2019/20, less than 1% of global climate finance was directed toward small-scale agri-food solutions. The small-scale agrifood systems are composed of a complex ecosystem of stakeholders including small-scale producers (typically managing less than 2 ha) and other value chain players (such as cooperatives, agri-micro, small- and medium-scale enterprises, and farmer associations). Despite forming 27% of the global workforce (873 million), smallholder farmers receive only a fraction of the global climate finance allocated under the small-scale agrifood systems.
Without the necessary financial support, transitioning to agroecology is out of reach for the majority of smallholder farmers. During the transition period, yields may be lower as new practices and crops are brought in. Lacking the financial resources to see them through this phase, many farmers already willing to restore their soils are unable to do so.
The proposed solution is to ease access to, and increase climate finance to support farmers in the transition to regenerative agroecology. This approach will improve soil health, enhance carbon sequestration, and strengthen food security while building climate resilience, supporting biodiversity and providing other ecosystem benefits including flood and drought prevention.
Key policy recommendations include:
Making climate finance accessible to farmers for adopting regenerative agroecological practices
Increasing climate finance allocation to farmers for creating carbon sinks in farmlands
Developing supportive policies and infrastructure for adopting sustainable land practices
Mobilizing private investment into soil regeneration
Integrating soil restoration into climate finance strategies
Background
Healthy, living soil is the basis of all life-making processes and is critical in sustaining humanity and all other life forms on Earth. Responsible for strengthening food security, securing farmer livelihoods, water resources, biodiversity, air quality, and building climate resilience in the agriculture sector, soil health is the bedrock of societies across the globe.
Organic matter is key to healthy soil, acting as food for the microorganisms necessary to build a robust soil food web that supplies plants with essential nutrients. As 58% of organic matter is organic carbon, soil is therefore the largest terrestrial carbon sink, with the remarkable potential to hold three times more carbon than the atmosphere and all plant and animal life combined.
Agricultural lands occupy about one-third of the world’s total land area, comprising agricultural land, forest land, barren and desert areas, and urban land. Agricultural soils therefore are the only soils that are actively managed and maintained, making it compelling to transition them into active carbon sinks. This can be achieved by adopting simple, sustainable soil management practices or regenerative agriculture practices through agroecology, such as cover cropping, crop rotation, and no-tillage. Soils must be alive and healthy to meet a 60% higher global food demand by 2050 and almost 100% higher demand in emerging nations., With agriculture contributing substantially to National GDPs (4% in developed nations to 25% in some of the least developed countries), soil degradation also risks economic development across the globe.
Problem Statement
With over 40% of the world’s land already degraded, soils have become active carbon emitters. The UNFAO has warned that 90% of Earth's topsoil could be at risk by 2050, making agricultural soils one of the most significant carbon emitters globally. This trend of intensifying land degradation affects 3.2 billion people, and is primarily driven by the continued use of conventional agricultural practices (e.g. monocropping, injudicious use of chemicals, deep-plowing) worldwide.,
Agricultural soils can become carbon sinks if farmers are supported in adopting regenerative agroecological practices. This transition requires supporting farmers through education, access to expertise, hand-holding during the transition, and financial incentivisation for behavior change. In this brief, we will focus specifically on solving the financial incentivisation support farmers need.
By focusing on building health and life into soils, regenerative agricultural practices through agroecology have the potential to contribute around 27% of the global emission cuts needed to keep temperature rise below 2°C. Farmers, especially small-holder farmers who account for 84% of farms and produce around one-third of the world's food (and up to 70% of food in low- and middle-income countries), are central to this effort.
Despite forming 27% of the global workforce, and their crucial role in food production, small-holder farmers could only access a fraction of the 0.8% of total climate finance (USD 660.2 billion) invested in small-scale agrifood systems (2019/2020), impeding their transition to regenerative agroecological practices.
In contrast, 89% of global climate finance (on average between 2017 and 2020) was invested in mitigation actions driven by technological innovation in the production sector and in clean and renewable energy solutions.
Compounding this issue, nature-negative financial flows (those leading to environmental degradation, biodiversity loss, and ecosystem destruction) outpace nature-positive investments that promote a stable climate, and healthy land and nature, by a factor of 30 as of 2022. This imbalance accelerates climate change and ecological breakdown, making it even more critical to invest in soil health.
Solution: Climate Finance for Farmers
Redirecting financial flows towards developing healthy living soils through regenerative agroecological practices is imperative to realizing their carbon sink potential, strengthening food security, and providing other ecosystem benefits. Due to resource constraints, farmer adoption of regenerative practices, and therefore the realization of these benefits, is limited.
We call for immediate action to revitalize soil ecosystems by easing climate finance mechanisms that support smallholder farmers. Investing in agricultural soils means incentivising farmers to adopt regenerative practices through agroecology, including cover cropping, crop rotation, integrating plant and animal litter into the land, rotational grazing, agroforestry, and reduced usage of chemical inputs like fertilizers and pesticides.
Across the globe, many initiatives support farmers to realize the benefits of adopting such practices. These efforts have been fueled by individual small grants and crowdfunding from citizens and institutions. To scale up such interventions and make them available to all farmers worldwide, we will need to make climate finance more accessible. The following are policy recommendations to realize this.
Policy Recommendations
Increase climate finance allocation to support farmers' shift to sustainable agriculture: Prioritize grants, subsidies, and low-interest loans that enable them to adopt sustainable land management practices.
Make climate finance accessible to farmers through process-level monitoring rather than outcome-based monitoring. Since carbon sequestration in living agricultural soils happens at a prolonged rate, farmers should be incentivised to continuously manage their land sustainably. In the short term, monitoring systems used by crop insurance companies can be deployed to assess land management change. GIS-based imaging to track land-use changes and the effects of practices like cover cropping and tree-based farming can help monitor medium- and long-term progress.
Develop supportive policies and infrastructure for the transition to regenerative agroecological practices. This could include providing technical training, market access, and incentives for adopting regenerative practices that sequester carbon.
Mobilize private investment into nature-positive agriculture. The financial industry must take the lead in developing innovative instruments such as impact funds (designed to pass on a percentage of profits for large-scale adoption of regenerative practices), as well as debt instruments that recognise the outcomes (i.e. trees on land) as assets, comparable to a home that can be mortgaged.
Integrate soil restoration and other Nature-Based Solutions (NbS) into climate finance strategies, recognising their potential to sequester carbon and support ecosystem services.
There is no dearth of solutions and means to accomplish the needed soil carbon sequestration for climate mitigation and adaptation, there is only a dearth of time for the rapidly degrading soils, for the farmers who depend on it for their livelihoods, and for the global citizenry that depends on both. The urgency of allocating accessible and sufficient climate funding for farmers to adopt regenerative agroecological practices forms a big part of the puzzle to ameliorate the effects of climate change already disrupting lives, agri-food systems, socio-economic systems and natural ecosystems. As a group of organizations and UNFCCC-accredited NGOs that acknowledges the vital role agricultural soils and farmers play in climate change mitigation and adaptation, we encourage all NGOs that resonate with the policy recommendations put forth in this document to contribute their voices to realizing this cause.
Should this be of interest, we would kindly request your response through this form.
Response Form
About the authors
The International “4 per 1000” Initiative
Launched at UNFCCC CoP 21 in December 2015, the international "4 per 1000 Initiative: Soils for Food Security and Climate" aims to show that agriculture, and in particular agricultural soils through natural carbon sequestration, can provide concrete solutions to the challenge of climate change while at the same time meeting the challenge of food security by implementing agricultural practices adapted to local conditions. Based on solid scientific documentation, the international "4 per 1000" Initiative encourages all voluntary actors around the world to engage in a transition towards a regenerative, productive, highly resilient agriculture, based on appropriate management of land and soil such as agroecology. More information on https://4p1000.org/?lang=en, and by email at: secretariat@4p1000.org
Save Soil Movement
Save Soil (backed by the UNCCD, UNEP, WFP, UNFAO, IUCN amongst others) is a global people’s movement to address the soil degradation crisis, and support governments in implementing soil health policies to establish a minimum 3-6% organic matter in agricultural soil (subject to regional conditions.)The Save Soil movement’s ‘Cauvery Calling’ initiative has helped farmers multiply their income 3 to 5 times by helping over 220,000 farmers transition to tree-based agriculture and training over 27,000 farmers in regenerative agriculture practices.
SEKEM
SEKEM has made significant strides in supporting small-scale farmers and sustainable farming practices. Since its inception, SEKEM has reclaimed and developed over 830 hectares of land. They have trained 11780 farmers in biodynamic agriculture methods, which are now applied to 51,036 feddans (about 21,435 hectares). SEKEM’s network includes more than 13,342 farmers who produce for the SEKEM group. This holistic approach has not only restored barren land but also created numerous job opportunities, employing over 2,000 people.
Cite this source: Save Soil Movement, The International 4p1000 Initiative, SEKEM. "UNFCCC Policy Brief: Securing Our Future, Making Climate Finance Work for Agricultural Soil," Conscious Planet, 2024.
Endorsements from NGOs
SEKEM, Egypt
The 4p1000 Initiative
Conscious Planet - Save Soil
APPUI SOLIDARITÉ POUR LE RENFORCEMENT DE L' AIDE AU DÉVELOPPEMENT, Mali
ASRAD NGO, Mali
Seven Generations Ahead, USA
Universal Versatile Society , India
Regional Centre for International Development Cooperation - RCIDC, Uganda
Action pour le Respect et la Protection de l'Environnement - ARPE , Cameroon
SPECO - Sociedade Portuguesa de Ecologia , Portugal
Nourish Scotland, Scotland
Millennium Institute, USA
ECDPM, Belgium
Tropenbos International, The Netherlands
Portuguese Society of Soil Science (SPCS), Portugal
HUMUS+Modell Ökoregion Kaindorf, Austria
Gram Saarthi, India
GEOTA - Grupo de Estudos de Ordenamento do Território e Ambiente , Portugal
ALMARGEM - Associação de Defesa do Património Cultural e Ambiental do Algarve , Portugal
Bio-Foundation Switzerland/ Bio-Stiftung Schweiz , Switzerland
Alimentar Cidades Sustentáveis Associação (ACSA), Portugal
CIRAD, France
Climate & Sustainability, Switzerland
Soil Science Society of Switzerland
Climate Bridges , Switzerland
LAYA , India
Indian Network on Ethics and Climate Change , India
Équiterre, Canada
Earthworm Foundation, Switzerland
The Association of Balkan Eco-innovation, Serbia
Regenerative Agriculture Alliance of Serbia , Serbia
PELUM KENYA, Kenya
IDEAS For Us, USA
Labverde, Italy
Centre for Social and Sustainable Innovation, Canada
Gamble Creek Farms, USA
UCC Whale Center Inc, USA
Young Professionals for Agricultural Development(YPARD), Germany (Global Org)
Foundation Myclimate, Switzerland
Prakheti Agrologics, India
Sociedad Española de la Ciencia del Suelo (SECS), Spain
Centre for Livelihoods and Support to Sustainable development, Cameroon
RCA-The Association of Rwenzori community, Uganda
Association des agriculteurs sans frontières , Democratic Republic of Congo
CLIMATE CHANGE AFRICA OPPORTUNITIES - CCAO, Democratic Republic of Congo
RESEAU POUR LA SECURITE ET LA SOUVERAINETE ALIMENTAIRE EN RD CONGO - RESSAC, Democratic Republic of Congo
PILIER AUX FEMMES VYLNERABLES ACTIVES EN RD CONGO - PIFEVA, Democratic Republic of Congo
University of Life Sciences in Lublin, Poland
Associação Natureza Portugal | WWF, Portugal
Youth Path Organisation, Ghana
WeForest, Belgium
Asociación Nacional de Agricultura de Conservación AC, Mexico
International Union of Soil Sciences, Italy (Global)
Agreena, Denmark
Moulay Ismail University, Morocco
Goodwill Foods, Taiwan
Krisoker Sor (Farmers' Voice), Bangladesh
Kazakh Research Institute of Soil Science and Agrochemistry named after Uspanov, Kazakhstan
FONDATION ISHIABWE KITHOKO ANDRE, FONDIKA RDC, Democratic Republic of Congo
GREEN RUSH ORGANIC FARMS INC, USA
Plan Vivo Foundation, United Kingdom
US MEXICO FOUNDATION FOR SCIENCE, Mexico
Plant for the Planet Italia ODV, Italy
Fair River Int Association for Development (FARIAD), Ghana
Alexis Foundation, India
MONTPELLIER MEDITERRANEE METROPOLE, France
Youth Agro-Marine Development Association, Somalia
GIERI asbl, Republic Democratic of Congo
Carbon Sync, Australia
European Biogas Association, Belgium
Sustainable Planet LLC, USA
Acadian Plant Health, Canada
Longview Limited, New Zealand
Bio Suisse, Switzerland
Bulgarian Soil Science Society, Bulgaria
B the Light Consulting, USA
Faculty of Agriculture, University of Belgrade, Serbia
Proyectando un Ambiente y Sociedad Verde A.C., Mexico
¡HAGAMOS QUE SUCEDA!